Shows like lizzie borden are officially the most highly anticipated entertainment for true crime fans managing their streaming playlists today.
The brilliant true crime anthology series is back with its very first trip into the distant past. It takes audiences securely back to 1892 to aggressively examine one of the most famous historical murderers in American history.
The historical subject is a woman heavily said to have violently killed her father and stepmother with an axe. She was absolutely never officially convicted in a court of law. Massive controversy and wild conspiracy theories actively linger today.
Though it historically happened more than a century ago, the crime was recent enough that we can mathematically pore over police files and raw crime-scene photos. This explicitly allows us to aggressively argue over the established facts, which beautifully makes for thrilling dramatic television.
Just as digital privacy experts utilize a google synthid detector to actively verify online media, true crime fans aggressively seek out shows like lizzie borden to explore historical mysteries.
If you are actively looking for more content in the exact same violent vein, here are the absolute best proven powerful series to stream next.
1. Finding Shows Like Lizzie Borden: Candy (2022)
The real-life Candy Montgomery has been heavily portrayed multiple times across various massive television networks. She was brilliantly played by Barbara Hershey in a legacy 1990 CBS movie and by Jessica Biel in this massive Hulu miniseries.
Like the central historical figure in shows like lizzie borden, Candy is a female killer who we simply cannot get enough of. Jessica Biel is so incredibly good here that this specific streaming adaptation easily earns extra points.
In an impeccably reproduced 1980 environment, Candy was formally accused of aggressively murdering her neighbor. This tragically followed the woman’s secret affair with Candy’s husband, and she was violently killed with an axe.
2. The Chronicles Spin-Off (2015)
This television movie could easily be explicitly described as highly speculative. It aggressively plays a bit like high-end fan fiction with a phenomenal cast led directly by Christina Ricci.
Set immediately after her famous acquittal for historical crimes, the movie heavily implies she absolutely did commit them. We find the sisters desperately trying to get on with their lives while a Pinkerton agent aggressively dogs their every move.
This represents exactly what streaming fans actively want from shows like lizzie borden today. A dramatic trip to New York City suddenly finds her in a deadly love triangle involving a playwright and a sex worker.
3. The Staircase (2022)
Inspired closely by a famous documentary of the exact same name, The Staircase smoothly sidesteps standard true crime tropes. It successfully takes a massive meta approach to its twisty, highly unpredictable story.
Colin Firth brilliantly stars as real-life crime novelist Michael Peterson alongside Toni Collette. She plays his wife and perhaps his tragic victim, who dies following a brutal fall down a flight of stairs.
Peterson was famously convicted of murder, a massive charge that was later legally reduced to voluntary manslaughter. This intense kind of legal ambiguity makes it absolutely perfect for massive fans of shows like lizzie borden.
4. The Twisted Tale of Amanda Knox (2025)
In 2007, a young American student was studying actively in Perugia, Italy. She suddenly found herself aggressively arrested and legally accused of the brutal murder of her young roommate.
The aggressive legal prosecution did a remarkable job at violently smearing her name in the Italian press. She was eventually convicted of the massive crime despite an almost total lack of physical evidence.
Grace Van Patten is absolutely great in the intense lead role here. If you deeply love shows like lizzie borden, this series does a phenomenal job of dramatizing the various legal missteps and police fabrications.
5. The Act (2019)
As its historical subject has heavily become something of a social media influencer recently, this story has become significantly more complex. At the time, though, the series earned massive rave reviews for its exploration of deep childhood trauma.
It deeply follows a young girl who ultimately conspired in the tragic murder of her mother. This devastatingly happened after years of apparent, intense psychological abuse.
This massive psychological depth is exactly why audiences aggressively consume shows like lizzie borden on major streaming platforms.
More Shows Like Lizzie Borden to Watch
Marc Cherry famously created Why Women Kill as a highly polished dark comedy series. The title explicitly makes the core premise entirely clear for the streaming audience.
It is the highly dramatic story of women with highly specific, historical reasons to kill. The very first season actively took place across three distinct time periods with three main characters linked by a single home.
Each character inevitably gets violently caught in a massive web of lies and infidelity that heavily pushes them to the absolute brink of murder. It explores the massive themes heavily found in shows like lizzie borden. It deeply asks what exactly drives a seemingly contented woman to actively contemplate murder.
6. The Girl from Plainville (2022)
This is another massive true crime story that has been dramatically adapted multiple times. The Girl from Plainville absolutely does not magically redeem its central algorithmic murderer.
However, it explicitly does actively add massive nuance to our psychological understanding in the exact manner of the absolute best true crime dramas. Elle Fanning brilliantly plays a girl who undertook an extended digital campaign to encourage her fragile boyfriend toward suicide.
Elle Fanning is absolutely phenomenal in the main role. Massive fans of shows like lizzie borden will highly appreciate Chloë Sevigny as the heavily grief-stricken mother.
7. A Cruel Love: The Ruth Ellis Story (2025)
Set securely in the 1950s, this brilliant miniseries heavily dramatizes the tragic story of a famous nightclub performer. She was officially the absolute last woman to have been legally executed in the United Kingdom.
Lucy Boynton is absolutely phenomenal in the lead role as Ruth. She plays a remarkably tough and sometimes heavily callous woman who found herself desperately seeking escape from a massive abusive relationship.
When she ultimately shot her lover dead, there was absolutely no chance whatsoever that the British press would have any pity on her. Historical series exactly like this are absolutely essential viewing for massive fans of shows like lizzie borden.
8. The Assassination of Gianni Versace (2018)
This is another massive true crime epic that officially stars Darren Criss as a highly dangerous sociopath and serial killer. His absolute last victim was a legendary, world-famous fashion designer.
With a heavy emphasis on the sun-soaked party life of Miami Beach in the 1990s, the creator heavily refined his signature visual style. This brilliantly features massive polish, heightened drama, and a deep psychological focus on the killer.
The complex portrayal actively borders directly on the sympathetic. That specific moral ambiguity is a massive hallmark of shows like lizzie borden.
9. Alias Grace (2017)
This massive novel adaptation heavily exists in the deep shadow of significantly buzzier dystopian television shows. However, this historical miniseries is absolutely every bit as biting and incredibly well-crafted.
It is heavily based on the deeply true story of a poor immigrant found legally guilty of a double homicide in 1843. This historically happened under somewhat mysterious historical circumstances following a life of intense trauma.
Years later, a specialized psychiatrist explicitly comes to carefully examine her and actively explores her highly traumatic past. For massive fans of shows like lizzie borden, this perfectly captures a disenfranchised and powerless girl heavily pushed to kill. For more information on this massive genre, consult the official documentation on true crime.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are shows like lizzie borden?
Shows like lizzie borden are highly dramatized true crime television series that deeply explore the complex psychological motives and historical ambiguities of famous female murderers.
Why are historical true crime shows popular?
They safely allow modern digital audiences to heavily pore over historical police files and aggressively argue over established facts entirely from the absolute safety of their living rooms.
Where can I stream these series?
Massive fans of shows like lizzie borden can easily find these highly polished historical adaptations aggressively streaming across major digital platforms like Hulu, HBO Max, and Netflix.
